Your browser is out of date.
This site may not function properly in your current browser. Update Now

Finger Lakes Cookie Company


At Finger Lakes Cookie Company we create Old-Fashioned Cookies -- baked with love, fresh every day... thick, soft, chewy and incredibly large. All cookies are made with the finest local ingredients (including our Homemade Ice Cream from Yummies)!

Social Links


Closed until January 11.

Monday: CLOSED
Tuesday: 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM
Wednesday: 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM
Thursday: 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM
Friday: 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM
Saturday: CLOSED
Sunday: CLOSED

**About the Owner: **
Finger Lakes Cookies was founded by Lori A. Bush through a dream and a desire to carry on the legacy of her parents, Tom and Lois Bush, in helping community grow.

Through one cookie at a time, Lori has grown Finger Lakes Cookies into not only a small town storefront, but also a business that caters to weddings, corporate events, a business that caters to walk-in clients, small business events, large corporate events, SUNY Geneseo events, school fundraising efforts, bike races, 5Ks, corporate cookies, and fundraising opportunity.

The mission of Finger Lakes Cookies is to provide a venue in which through the purchase of each cookie a portion supports a need across our community locally, nationally, and internationally. Locally, we provide an internship program and employment opportunities for developmentally disabled adults. We believe communities are built on partnerships...."as it is through many that we can achieve much". We incorporate local wines, brews, and distills into our cookies making unique and amazingly delicious gourmet cookies. We, in addition, partner with local schools and local organizations to raise funds to make a difference in this world.

**Our Philanthropy: **
Day old cookies are donated to the local food pantry or Livingston/Wyoming ARC homes and 10% of all proceeds are donated directly to the Livingston/Wyoming ARC program.


Dessert Shop
Gourmet Cookies
Ice Cream
Corporate and Fundraising Cookies
Gift Certificates and Baskets
Holiday Packages
Online Ordering
Nation Wide Shipping

Nearby Places